Gross McGinley LLP

  • About
  • Attorneys
      • Safa Ashrafi
      • Kara M. Beck
      • Michael J. Blum
      • Robert M. Campbell
      • Thomas A. Capehart
      • Victor F. Cavacini
      • Sarah Hart Charette
      • Samuel E. Cohen
      • Adrian K. Cousens
      • J. Jackson Eaton, III
      • Malcolm J. Gross 
      • John F. "Jack" Gross
      • Kimberly G. Krupka
      • Anne K. Manley
      • Paul A. McGinley
      • R. Nicholas Nanovic
      • Constance K. Nelson
      • Kellie L. Rahl-Heffner
      • H. Ross Ramaley
      • Patrick J. Reilly
      • Thomas E. Reilly, Jr.
      • Nicholas Sandercock
      • Graig M. Schultz
      • Stuart T. Shmookler
      • Loren L. Speziale
      • Howard S. Stevens
      • Allen I. Tullar
      • Jason A. Ulrich
      • Jennifer L. Weed
      •  
      • View All Attorneys
      • View All Paralegals
  • Practice Areas
      • Business Law
      • Criminal Defense
      • Divorce and Family Law
      • Elder Law
      • Employment Law
      • Insurance Defense
      • Intellectual Property
      • Internet Law
      • Litigation
      • Medical Malpractice Defense
      • Real Estate
      • Tax Law
      • Wills, Trusts, & Estates
      •  
  • Industries
      • Banking
      • Health Care
      • Media and Publishing
      • Municipal
      • Non-Profit
      •  
  • News
      • Gross McGinley Law Firm Donates $13,000 to Greater Lehigh Valley Nonprofits
        Dec 18th, 2020| Firm News
      • Gross McGinley Promotes Sarah Hart Charette and Kellie Rahl-Heffner to Partner Attorneys
        Dec 18th, 2020| Attorney News
      • Gross McGinley Launches Giving Back Tuesday 2020 Program
        Nov 19th, 2020| Firm News
  • Blog
      • Can Employers Require the COVID-19 Vaccination?
        Jan 18th, 2021
      • Can I Get Pulled Over for Violating Coronavirus Travel Restrictions?
        Jan 8th, 2021
      • More Business Restrictions in PA Adversely Impact Small Businesses
        Dec 11th, 2020
  • Careers
  • 610.820.5450
  • Contact Us
  • Make a Payment

Following CDC and state guidance, we are offering in-person and remote legal services to our clients. Please call us at 610.820.5450 for assistance with your legal needs or visit our COVID-19 page for insights on pandemic-related matters.

gross-headerimg-2
Gross McGinley LLP > Blog > Third Circuit Upholds Asbestos Exclusion in Insurance…
Blog Disclaimer

Blog Disclaimer

This Blog is intended for educational and informational purposes and intended to only provide you with a general understanding of the law, not to provide any legal advice, including on the subject of the Blog. Laws that may pertain to this Blog will vary by jurisdiction, and the information on this blog may not apply to you. The content within this Blog is not intended, and should not be construed, in any way to be legal advice and thus you should not rely on any information provided in the Blog as legal advice. You should consult with appropriate legal counsel concerning any issues for which legal advice may be needed. Your review or use of the Blog and the content therein is not intended to create, and does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Please contact us if you have any questions about a Blog or would like more information, but, by contacting us, no attorney-client relationship is formed between you and Gross McGinley, LLP, including the Blog author. Do not send any confidential information to Gross McGinley, LLP or the authors of the Blog without first speaking to one of our lawyers and receiving our permission to provide confidential information. Unsolicited confidential information sent to us may not be subject to an attorney-client privilege and may not be treated as confidential. This Blog is not published for advertising or solicitation purposes. Gross McGinley, LLP disclaims all liability to all persons for any claim, loss, liability or any damages that may arise in connection with the Blog and any content or information contained in the Blog. Even though we strive to create our Blog content based on our current understanding of the law, we cannot and do not guarantee that the content and information in the Blog is current, accurate, or complete. Gross McGinley, LLP owns the copyright in the Blog, which is protected by federal and state laws, including copyright laws. The Blog cannot be altered or modified in any way. A copy of the Blog may be used and printed only for personal, educational, informational and noncommercial purposes. The Blog cannot be used for any other purpose without the express permission of Gross McGinley, LLP.

Third Circuit Upholds Asbestos Exclusion in Insurance Policy

Written by: Adrian K. Cousens on August 02, 2017 | Category: Blog | Tags: Insurance Defense, Litigation

    Share

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Plus
  • LinkedIn

In a closely watched decision, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously overturned a decision of an Eastern District of Pennsylvania Court finding ambiguity in an excess insurance policy exclusion, relieving Travelers Insurance of a $36 million indemnity obligation. See Gen. Refractories Co. v. First State Ins. Co, 855 F.3d 152 (3d Cir. 2017).

At the heart of the case was litigation involving General Refractories Co. (GRC), a manufacturer and supplier of products that contained asbestos sold back as far as 1978. Over 30,000 lawsuits were brought against GRC and its various primary liability insurance policies were exhausted by 2002. GRC then tendered the claims to a series of excess insurers, including Appellant Travelers Surety and Casualty Company. The other excess carriers settled out of the litigation, leaving Travelers to be the only remaining insurer in the case. At the heart of the argument, Travelers claimed that it was not obligated to indemnify GRC in the remaining asbestos lawsuits, per language of an exclusion in the policy that provided:

“It is agreed that this policy does not apply to EXCESS NET LOSS arising out of asbestos, including but not limited to bodily injury arising out of asbestosis or related diseases or to property damage.”

GRC argued that an ambiguity existed in the exclusion because ‘asbestos’ could be interpreted as both the raw material of asbestos or as asbestos containing products. GRC’s suits involved asbestos containing products and not the “mining, milling, producing, processing, or manufacturing the raw mineral”.

The District Court agreed with GRC and found that Travelers could not meet its burden to show that GRC’s narrow interpretation was unreasonable. Accordingly, the Court ruled the exclusion unenforceable and ruled that Travelers must cover $21 million of GRC’s losses plus over $15 million in prejudgment interest.

The Third Circuit reversed the lower Court unanimously, ruling that the term “arising out of,” when used in a Pennsylvania insurance exclusion, unambiguously requires “but for” causation. The Court noted that “The provision plainly encompasses losses that would not have occurred but for asbestos or which are causally connected to asbestos. Pennsylvania law permits no other interpretation.”


Attorney Adrian K. Cousens is an experienced litigator, representing insurance companies in insurance defense cases involving a wide range of matters involving commercial and individual insureds.

News/Blog Archives

  • 2021
    • January 2021 (2)
  • 2020 • 2019 • 2018 • 2017 • 2016 • 2015 2014 • 2013 • 2012 • 2011 • 2010 • 2009 • 2008 2007 • 2006 • 2005 • 2004 • 2003 • 2000

Popular Tags

  • Community Involvement (221)
  • Litigation (127)
  • Employment Law (104)
  • Estate Planning & Administration (77)
  • Business Law (74)
  • COVID-19 (57)
  • Intellectual Property (51)
Criminal Defense

Spotlight: Criminal Defense

Gross McGinley’s experienced legal team has an extensive background in the area of general criminal defense. Our firm understands that everyone can find themselves in a set of circumstances that can lead to c… Read More

Sign up for Legal Updates

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Meet the Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
  • News & Blog
Next Previous
  • Allen I. Tullar view profile

  • Kimberly G. Krupka view profile

  • Kellie L. Rahl-Heffner view profile

11 View All Attorneys
  • Local Counsel

    Local Counsel

    more info
  • Litigation

    Litigation

    more info
  • Employment Law

    Employment Law

    more info
5 View All Practice Areas
  • Can Employers Require the COVID-19 Vaccination?

    Can Employers Require the COVID-19 Vaccinatio…

    continue reading
  • Can I Get Pulled Over for Violating Coronavirus Travel Restrictions?

    Can I Get Pulled Over for Violating Coronavir…

    continue reading
  • Gross McGinley Law Firm Donates $13,000 to Greater Lehigh Valley Nonprofits

    Gross McGinley Law Firm Donates $13,000 to Gr…

    continue reading
336 View Blog
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Super Lawyers Million Dollar Advocates NBLSC Board Certified Lawyers
Our Locations: Allentown • Easton • Lehighton
  • Allentown 33 S. Seventh Street, P.O. Box 4060
    Allentown, PA 18105-4060
    Telephone: (610) 820-5450
    Fax: (610) 820-6006
  • Easton 101 Larry Holmes Drive, Suite 202
    Easton, PA 18042
    Telephone: (610) 258-1506
    Fax: (610) 820-6006
  • Lehighton 415 Mahoning St.
    Suite A
    Lehighton, PA 18235
    Telephone: (610) 820-5450
    Fax: (610) 820-6006

Copyright © 2021 Gross McGinley LLP. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy and Terms of Use Secure File Portal