Gross McGinley LLP

Blog Disclaimer

Blog Disclaimer

This Blog is intended for educational and informational purposes and intended to only provide you with a general understanding of the law, not to provide any legal advice, including on the subject of the Blog. Laws that may pertain to this Blog will vary by jurisdiction, and the information on this blog may not apply to you. The content within this Blog is not intended, and should not be construed, in any way to be legal advice and thus you should not rely on any information provided in the Blog as legal advice. You should consult with appropriate legal counsel concerning any issues for which legal advice may be needed. Your review or use of the Blog and the content therein is not intended to create, and does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. Please contact us if you have any questions about a Blog or would like more information, but, by contacting us, no attorney-client relationship is formed between you and Gross McGinley, LLP, including the Blog author. Do not send any confidential information to Gross McGinley, LLP or the authors of the Blog without first speaking to one of our lawyers and receiving our permission to provide confidential information. Unsolicited confidential information sent to us may not be subject to an attorney-client privilege and may not be treated as confidential. This Blog is not published for advertising or solicitation purposes. Gross McGinley, LLP disclaims all liability to all persons for any claim, loss, liability or any damages that may arise in connection with the Blog and any content or information contained in the Blog. Even though we strive to create our Blog content based on our current understanding of the law, we cannot and do not guarantee that the content and information in the Blog is current, accurate, or complete. Gross McGinley, LLP owns the copyright in the Blog, which is protected by federal and state laws, including copyright laws. The Blog cannot be altered or modified in any way. A copy of the Blog may be used and printed only for personal, educational, informational and noncommercial purposes. The Blog cannot be used for any other purpose without the express permission of Gross McGinley, LLP.

PA Supreme Court Confirms Confidentiality of Attorney- Expert Communications

Written by: Kimberly G. Krupka on July 16, 2014 | Category: Blog | Tags:

In cases of professional negligence (such as medical malpractice), each party is required to present at trial the opinions of expert witnesses.  Prior to testifying in the Courtroom, the expert must author a written report providing all parties with sufficient notice of the expert’s opinions.  It is customary for the attorney and the expert to collaborate to perfect the content and style of the report before it is produced to opposing counsel.  A question has long existed as to the extent that such communications are protected by the Attorney Work Product Doctrine.  As reported previously, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a per curiam opinion on April 29, 2014, affirming the Order of the Superior Court denying discovery of communications between attorneys and expert witnesses.  Barrick v. Holy Spirit Hosp.,  91 A.3d 680 (Pa. April 29, 2014).  However, as this was a decision of an evenly divided Court, many attorneys continued to worry as to whether future communications would continue to remain confidential.  In the event new Justices were sitting on the Court and the issue was heard again, the ultimate determination of confidentiality could change.

On July 10, 2014 the Pennsylvania Supreme Court approved an amendment to Rule 4003.5 making it clear that attorney-expert communications are not discoverable in Pennsylvania.  There is no longer a lingering concern as to whether communications will continue to be protected in the future.  Absent a Rule change (which would provide notice to all counsel), communications are clearly protected.


Attorney Kimberly Krupka regularly works with expert witnesses as a member of the firm’s Medical Malpractice Defense Group.

Next Previous
View All Attorneys
View All Practice Areas
View Blog