Gross McGinley LLP

  • About
  • Attorneys
      • Safa Ashrafi
      • Kara M. Beck
      • Michael J. Blum
      • Robert M. Campbell
      • Thomas A. Capehart
      • Victor F. Cavacini
      • Sarah Hart Charette
      • Samuel E. Cohen
      • Adrian K. Cousens
      • J. Jackson Eaton, III
      • Malcolm J. Gross 
      • John F. "Jack" Gross
      • Kimberly G. Krupka
      • Anne K. Manley
      • Paul A. McGinley
      • R. Nicholas Nanovic
      • Constance K. Nelson
      • Kellie L. Rahl-Heffner
      • H. Ross Ramaley
      • Patrick J. Reilly
      • Thomas E. Reilly, Jr.
      • Nicholas Sandercock
      • Graig M. Schultz
      • Stuart T. Shmookler
      • Loren L. Speziale
      • Howard S. Stevens
      • Allen I. Tullar
      • Jason A. Ulrich
      • Jennifer L. Weed
      •  
      • View All Attorneys
      • View All Paralegals
  • Practice Areas
      • Business Law
      • Criminal Defense
      • Divorce and Family Law
      • Elder Law
      • Employment Law
      • Insurance Defense
      • Intellectual Property
      • Internet Law
      • Litigation
      • Medical Malpractice Defense
      • Real Estate
      • Tax Law
      • Wills, Trusts, & Estates
      •  
  • Industries
      • Banking
      • Health Care
      • Media and Publishing
      • Municipal
      • Non-Profit
      •  
  • News
      • Gross McGinley Law Firm Donates $13,000 to Greater Lehigh Valley Nonprofits
        Dec 18th, 2020| Firm News
      • Gross McGinley Promotes Sarah Hart Charette and Kellie Rahl-Heffner to Partner Attorneys
        Dec 18th, 2020| Attorney News
      • Gross McGinley Launches Giving Back Tuesday 2020 Program
        Nov 19th, 2020| Firm News
  • Blog
      • Achieving Justice Safely During COVID-19 Trials
        Jan 22nd, 2021
      • Is My Bar or Restaurant Eligible for a Round 2 PPP Loan?
        Jan 19th, 2021
      • Can Employers Require the COVID-19 Vaccination?
        Jan 18th, 2021
  • Careers
  • 610.820.5450
  • Contact Us
  • Make a Payment

Following CDC and state guidance, we are offering in-person and remote legal services to our clients. Please call us at 610.820.5450 for assistance with your legal needs or visit our COVID-19 page for insights on pandemic-related matters.

gross-headerimg-2
Gross McGinley LLP > News > Third Circuit Takes Hard Swing at Interchange Prohibition

Third Circuit Takes Hard Swing at Interchange Prohibition

July 30, 2019 | Category: News | Tags: Litigation

    Share

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Plus
  • LinkedIn

Citing the First Amendment, a federal appeals court took a hard swing at Pennsylvania’s “Interchange Prohibition” that limits billboards near interchanges. The ruling (Adams v. Pennsylvania Department of Transportation), issued on July 15, 2019, was a victory for Adams Outdoor Advertising. As other states have similar laws, this case is gaining traction in the billboard industry and could influence future arguments made by outdoor advertisers, nationwide.

The Third Circuit Court ruled that elements of the Pennsylvania Outdoor Advertising Control Act on its face raises a serious question of validity under the U.S. Constitution for the reason that the Act restricts the placement of billboards near highway interchanges, but imposes no such limitation for other types of signs. For example, a billboard having a commercial message, but more importantly, a political and/or social expression, is prohibited at an interchange on a federal aid primary highway, but a sign advertising a hotel at that location can be unlimited as to size, height, and location. Even a hotel sign having a size of a million square feet! The Third Circuit affirmed what Adams perceived the Interchange Prohibition as disparate treatment without any basis.

The recent decision handed down by Judge Ambro of the Third Circuit remands the case back to the federal trial court requiring the Pennsylvania Secretary of Transportation to show that the interchange provision does not violate the First Amendment, stating:

“(PennDOT) Secretary Richards bears the burden to justify the restraint it imposes and the exemptions it provides . . . She has not done so on the current record. On remand, she will have that chance.”

Attorneys Victor Cavacini and Kellie Rahl-Heffner worked extensively to reverse the disparity of regulation accorded to signs under the Act. The lawsuit claimed the prohibition violates the U.S. Constitution because it permits some forms of speech over others.

The decision stemmed from Adams’ original application for a PennDOT permit in 2016 to erect a billboard along Route 22 in Hanover Township near the 512 interchange. PennDOT denied the permit application after the permit sat as “pending” for over a year and after Adams filed its lawsuit. The Third Circuit determined that the lack of a deadline for PennDOT to either approve or deny a permit was itself unconstitutional.

This appellate decision is a significant decision in favor of Adams and the billboard industry, which is gaining national attention from outdoor advertising companies from around the country. PennDOT’s Interchange Provision mirrors the federally regulated Highway Beautification Act throughout the country. The Third Circuit decision is an important precedent furthering the importance of the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights as applied to sign regulation.


Victor Cavacini has extensive experience representing billboard companies in zoning applications and litigation matters related to signage location and municipal ordinances. He has specific experience with digital signage and the unique rules and permits required.

Kellie Rahl-Heffner is a member of Gross McGinley’s litigation team, frequently assisting in substantial litigation cases.

News/Blog Archives

  • 2021
    • January 2021 (4)
  • 2020 • 2019 • 2018 • 2017 • 2016 • 2015 2014 • 2013 • 2012 • 2011 • 2010 • 2009 • 2008 2007 • 2006 • 2005 • 2004 • 2003 • 2000

Popular Tags

  • Community Involvement (221)
  • Litigation (128)
  • Employment Law (104)
  • Estate Planning & Administration (77)
  • Business Law (75)
  • COVID-19 (59)
  • Intellectual Property (51)
Real Estate

Spotlight: Real Estate

Gross McGinley offers commercial and residential real estate legal services to individuals and businesses. Our experienced group of real estate attorneys and licensed title agents handle transactions of all typ… Read More

Sign up for Legal Updates

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Meet the Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
  • News & Blog
Next Previous
  • Anne K. Manley view profile

  • Allen I. Tullar view profile

  • Malcolm J. Gross  view profile

11 View All Attorneys
  • Real Estate

    Real Estate

    more info
  • Criminal Defense

    Criminal Defense

    more info
  • Litigation

    Litigation

    more info
5 View All Practice Areas
  • Achieving Justice Safely During COVID-19 Trials

    Achieving Justice Safely During COVID-19 Tria…

    continue reading
  • Is My Bar or Restaurant Eligible for a Round 2 PPP Loan?

    Is My Bar or Restaurant Eligible for a Round …

    continue reading
  • Can Employers Require the COVID-19 Vaccination?

    Can Employers Require the COVID-19 Vaccinatio…

    continue reading
337 View Blog
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Super Lawyers Million Dollar Advocates NBLSC Board Certified Lawyers
Our Locations: Allentown • Easton • Lehighton
  • Allentown 33 S. Seventh Street, P.O. Box 4060
    Allentown, PA 18105-4060
    Telephone: (610) 820-5450
    Fax: (610) 820-6006
  • Easton 101 Larry Holmes Drive, Suite 202
    Easton, PA 18042
    Telephone: (610) 258-1506
    Fax: (610) 820-6006
  • Lehighton 415 Mahoning St.
    Suite A
    Lehighton, PA 18235
    Telephone: (610) 820-5450
    Fax: (610) 820-6006

Copyright © 2021 Gross McGinley LLP. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy and Terms of Use Secure File Portal